Fair Chance and Ban-the-Box Laws: What the Ralphs and FedEx Settlements Mean for Employers

In July 2026, Ralphs agreed to pay $200,000 and change how it hires across California to settle the state's first lawsuit under the Fair Chance Act. A month earlier, FedEx paid $85,000 after a contractor turned away a driver because of an old conviction. Both cases were about process: when the employer asked about criminal history, how it assessed it, and what it told the applicant.

Fair chance laws, often called ban-the-box laws, are not limited to California. They exist across the country. A 2023 EEOC report counted 14 states and 20 localities that apply them to private employers, and many more that cover public employers and government contractors.

Federal contractors have their own rule. Under the federal Fair Chance to Compete for Jobs Act, a company with a federal contract cannot ask an applicant about criminal history before a conditional offer when the position is related to work under that contract. The Senate committee report says the federal law was written to reach prime contractors, not subcontractors. Subcontractors are still covered by the state and local laws where they hire, and a prime contractor may require the same practice in its subcontracts.

What do the Ralphs and FedEx settlements mean for employers?

Short answer: Employers that use criminal background checks are being held to each step of the process. California's Fair Chance Act lets an employer consider conviction history only after a conditional offer. Before withdrawing that offer, the employer must complete an individualized assessment, send a written preliminary notice, allow at least five business days for a response, and send a written final notice. Ralphs and FedEx both settled claims that they skipped parts of that process. Similar rules apply in Philadelphia, New York City and New Jersey, and the EEOC's October 2026 decision to withdraw its federal guidance does not change any of them.

Key takeaways

  • Ralphs will pay $200,000 and overhaul its hiring. The settlement, announced July 9, 2026, resolves a lawsuit California filed in 2023. It still needs court approval.
  • FedEx paid $85,000 over one applicant. A contractor rejected a driver based on an old, unrelated offense, and the state found that FedEx violated the law.
  • The alleged violations were mostly procedural. Asking too early, skipping the individualized assessment and sending incomplete notices.
  • One complaint is enough. Both cases began with individual applicants filing complaints with the state.
  • The federal rollback doesn't help. The EEOC withdrew its 2012 criminal records guidance on October 28, 2026, but state and local fair chance laws are unchanged.
  • Pennsylvania, New Jersey and New York employers have their own rules. Philadelphia tightened its ordinance effective January 6, 2026.

What happened in the Ralphs Fair Chance Act case?

Ralphs Grocery Company agreed to pay $200,000 and change its hiring practices to settle a lawsuit brought by the California Civil Rights Department (CRD). CRD announced the settlement on July 9, 2026. Ralphs did not admit wrongdoing, and the terms take effect only if the court approves the settlement.

CRD filed the case in December 2023 and called it the first lawsuit of its kind under the Fair Chance Act. The complaint alleged that Ralphs:

  • asked about conviction history on its job application, before any conditional offer

  • did not conduct individualized assessments of applicants' conviction histories

  • sent notices that did not adequately explain why an offer was being withdrawn

  • gave applicants no way to contest a denial or submit evidence of rehabilitation

  • refused to hire hundreds of applicants whose records did not justify a denial

CRD's examples included applicants who lost job offers over a single misdemeanor count of excessive noise and over out-of-state convictions for simple cannabis possession.

Term What Ralphs must do
Payment Pay $200,000 to compensate the four applicants who filed complaints with the state
Applications Remove all conviction history questions from applications for California positions
Notices Revise its adverse action notices to comply with the Fair Chance Act
Policy review Hire a consultant to review its hiring policies and recommend changes
Training Train the staff who assess applicants, including on research about people with past convictions
Reporting Report to CRD for three years on any job denial based on conviction history

What happened in the FedEx Fair Chance Act case?

FedEx agreed to pay $85,000 to one applicant and change its California hiring practices. CRD announced the settlement on June 3, 2026. FedEx did not admit liability.

The applicant applied for a driving job with a FedEx contractor in Riverside County. According to CRD, a contractor rejected the applicant because of an old and unrelated offense. The applicant's 2024 complaint named both FedEx and the contractor and alleged that the companies:

  • did not adequately assess whether the conviction related to the duties of the job

  • did not clearly tell the applicant about the right to submit evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances

  • never notified the applicant of the final decision to withdraw the conditional offer

CRD investigated and determined that FedEx had violated the Act. The case then settled in mediation. FedEx agreed to:

  • train the employees who review applicant backgrounds

  • create a California-specific job aid for staff who perform individualized assessments

  • revise its adverse action notices for all California applicants

Why does the FedEx case matter for companies that use contractors or staffing firms?

The rejection came from a contractor, and FedEx still paid and agreed to change its own process. If your company sets background check standards for contractors, staffing agencies or franchisees, or reviews the results, expect a regulator to look at your role as well as theirs.

What does California's Fair Chance Act require?

The Fair Chance Act (Government Code section 12952) applies to public and private employers with five or more employees. It controls when an employer can ask about criminal history and what it must do before rejecting someone because of it.

Step What the employer must do
1. Before a conditional offer Do not ask about or consider conviction history. Keep the question off applications and out of interviews.
2. After a conditional offer A criminal background check is allowed.
3. Individualized assessment Before withdrawing the offer, weigh the nature and gravity of the offense, the time that has passed, and the nature of the job. The conviction must have a direct and adverse relationship to the specific duties.
4. Preliminary notice Tell the applicant in writing which conviction is the problem, include a copy of the report, and explain the right to respond.
5. Time to respond Allow at least five business days. If the applicant disputes the accuracy of the record, allow at least five more.
6. Reassessment Consider whatever the applicant submits, including evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances.
7. Final notice Give the final decision in writing, with any internal appeal procedure and the right to file a complaint with CRD.

Employers can never consider arrests that did not lead to conviction, completed diversion programs, or convictions that were sealed, dismissed or expunged. CRD publishes an FAQ and sample forms for each step.

What mistakes do the Ralphs and FedEx cases have in common?

Both cases turned on gaps between the required process and what happened to actual applicants.

Alleged mistake Case What the law requires
Conviction question on the job application Ralphs No questions about conviction history before a conditional offer
No real individualized assessment Ralphs, FedEx A job-specific review of the offense, its age and the duties of the role
Rejecting people for old or minor offenses Ralphs, FedEx A direct and adverse relationship between the conviction and the job
Incomplete or unclear preliminary notice Ralphs, FedEx Written notice naming the conviction and explaining the right to respond
No chance to show rehabilitation Ralphs, FedEx At least five business days to respond, and real consideration of the response
No final notice FedEx A written final decision that includes complaint rights
Decision made by a contractor FedEx The same steps, whoever makes the decision

Does the EEOC's withdrawal of its criminal records guidance change this?

No. On October 28, 2026, the EEOC voted to rescind its 2012 enforcement guidance on arrest and conviction records, effective immediately. That guidance explained how an employer's use of criminal records could amount to race or national origin discrimination under Title VII.

Three points matter for employers:

  • State and local laws are untouched. The Fair Chance Act and local ordinances impose their own requirements, and state and city agencies enforce them.

  • Title VII still applies. The EEOC's announcement says the rescission does not give employers license to discriminate.

  • You don't have to change anything. The EEOC said the rescission does not require employers to abandon lawful practices they adopted in response to the guidance.

An employer that drops individualized assessments because of the federal change would be out of compliance in California, Philadelphia and New York City.

Which states and cities have ban-the-box or fair chance laws?

Jurisdiction Who is covered When you can ask Key requirements
Federal contractors Companies with a federal contract, for positions related to work under that contract After a conditional offer The federal law controls timing only. It was written to reach prime contractors. State and local laws still apply.
California Employers with five or more employees After a conditional offer Individualized assessment, written preliminary and final notices, and at least five business days to respond.
Pennsylvania (statewide) All employers No statewide timing rule Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 9125, felony and misdemeanor convictions may be considered only to the extent they relate to suitability for the job. The applicant must be told in writing if the record is the reason for a denial.
Philadelphia Employers with one or more employees After a conditional offer Individualized assessment. Felonies can be considered for 7 years and misdemeanors for 4. Summary offenses cannot be considered. The applicant gets 10 business days to respond.
New Jersey Employers with 15 or more employees After the first interview No criminal record questions on applications or in the first interview, and no job ads that exclude people with records.
New York State Most employers No statewide timing rule Under Article 23-A of the Correction Law, an employer cannot deny a job because of a conviction unless it is directly related to the job or hiring the person would create an unreasonable risk.
New York City Employers with four or more employees After a conditional offer A written Fair Chance analysis shared with the applicant, and at least five business days to respond before the decision is final.
Delaware Public employers only After the first interview The state law places no requirements on private employers. Public employers must weigh the offense, the time passed and the job.
Maryland Employers with 15 or more full-time employees At the first interview, in person or by phone or video Employers that serve minors or vulnerable adults are exempt. Baltimore City, Montgomery County and Prince George's County have their own, stricter rules.
Massachusetts Most employers After the initial written application Some records can never be asked about, including misdemeanor convictions more than three years old. The applicant must get a copy of the record before an adverse decision.
Connecticut Employers generally After the initial employment application No questions about arrests, charges or convictions on the initial application unless a law requires it or the job requires a bond.
Illinois Most employers After the applicant is selected for an interview or given a conditional offer A conviction can be used only if it has a substantial relationship to the job or creates an unreasonable risk. Written preliminary notice, at least five business days to respond, and a written final notice.
Washington State Employers with 15 or more employees since July 1, 2026, and all others from January 1, 2027 After a conditional offer A legitimate business reason is required. The employer must identify the record, hold the job open at least two business days, and give a written decision.

Philadelphia amended its ordinance effective January 6, 2026. The changes shortened the look-back period for misdemeanors, required employers to consider evidence of rehabilitation, and allow the city to presume retaliation when an employer takes adverse action within 90 days of someone exercising their rights.

Can employers in regulated industries still rely on a list of prohibited offenses?

Less and less. Many employers in health care and human services are required to run criminal background checks, and for years the law also told them which convictions barred a hire. Several of those fixed lists have been struck down or replaced with case-by-case review. The check is still mandatory, but the decision now belongs to the employer.

Pennsylvania (as an example) shows how this works.

  • Care of older and vulnerable adults. The Older Adults Protective Services Act listed offenses that barred a person from working in a covered facility, some of them for life. In Peake v. Commonwealth (2015), the Commonwealth Court held that the lifetime ban violated the Pennsylvania Constitution. The Department of Aging says background checks are still required and recommends an individualized risk assessment for each applicant.

  • Intellectual disability and autism services. The Department of Human Services' compliance guide for community homes tells providers to keep running the checks, but says the Department may no longer preclude hiring a person convicted of a listed offense. Providers are told to weigh the nature of the crime, the facts of the conviction, the time elapsed, evidence of rehabilitation and the requirements of the job.

  • Nursing facilities. State regulations adopted in 2022 responded to Peake by calling for a determination of each employee's suitability for employment, kept in the personnel file.

  • Mental health services. The regulation for psychiatric outpatient clinics requires a completed criminal history check for staff who have direct contact with individuals, and a written policy on personnel decisions based on the results. It lists no disqualifying offenses and no look-back period. The state's compliance guide points clinics to the same case-by-case factors.

Why does this matter for employers?

A provider used to be able to reject a candidate by pointing to the statute. Now a rejection based on a listed offense and a decision to hire despite one both need a documented reason. In practice that means:

The risk is higher for these employers than for one that never runs a check. Because the check is mandatory, the employer always knows about the conviction. If it hires the person and someone is later harmed, that knowledge can support a negligent hiring claim. If it rejects the person, it has to defend the decision under fair chance and anti-discrimination laws, with no statute to point to. A mandate to run the check, with no guidance on whom to exclude, leaves the employer exposed in both directions. The written assessment is its main protection.

The risk is highest where the law requires the check but gives no guidance on whom to exclude. Once the check is done, the employer knows about the record. If it hires the person and something goes wrong, that knowledge can support a negligent hiring claim. If it rejects the person, it has to justify the decision under fair chance and anti-discrimination laws. With no list to point to, the employer's own written assessment is its only defense in either direction.

  • complete a written individualized assessment for every applicant whose check shows a conviction

  • keep the rationale in the personnel file, whether the answer is yes or no

  • adopt a written policy that sets your own criteria, including how far back you look, and apply it consistently

  • confirm which fixed bars still apply. Pennsylvania's Child Protective Services Law, for example, still disqualifies people with certain convictions from jobs involving contact with children.

  • if your agency still relies on a list of prohibited offenses, check periodically that the blanket prohibition is still in force. Courts and regulators have removed several of these lists, and an employer that keeps applying one after it is gone is rejecting people with no legal basis. Review the statute, the regulation and the licensing agency's current guidance at least once a year, and whenever a license is renewed.

Providers in Philadelphia should also check how the city's fair chance ordinance applies to them.

How does the Fair Credit Reporting Act fit with fair chance laws?

They apply together. The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) governs any background check an employer buys from a screening company. Fair chance laws add state and local steps on top of it. Following one does not satisfy the other.

What does the FCRA require?

The FTC's guidance for employers sets out three stages.

Stage What the FCRA requires
Before ordering the report Tell the applicant in writing, in a stand-alone document, that you may use a background report for employment decisions, and get written authorization. The notice can't be part of the job application.
Before adverse action Give the applicant a copy of the report you relied on and a copy of "A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act."
After adverse action Give notice of the decision with the screening company's name, address and phone number, a statement that the company did not make the decision and can't explain it, and notice of the right to dispute the report and to get a free copy within 60 days.

The FCRA does not say how long to wait between the pre-adverse action notice and the final decision. An FTC staff opinion says only that some time must pass so the person can respond.

How do FCRA notices and fair chance notices differ?

Item FCRA Fair chance laws (California as the example)
Applies when You use a report from a screening company You consider conviction history from any source
First notice A copy of the report and the summary of rights Names the disqualifying conviction, includes the report, and explains the right to respond with evidence of rehabilitation or mitigation
Waiting period Not specified At least five business days in California, and ten in Philadelphia
Final notice The screening company's contact details and dispute rights The final decision, any internal appeal procedure and the right to file a complaint with the state

Where do adverse action notices go wrong?

  • Using a vendor's FCRA templates alone. They don't name the conviction, explain rehabilitation rights or mention the state agency. Ralphs and FedEx both agreed to revise their adverse action notices.

  • Counting the wrong deadline. A short FCRA waiting period can cut off the response time a fair chance law guarantees.

  • Putting the disclosure in the application. The FCRA requires a stand-alone document. In New York City, an authorization signed before the conditional offer cannot mention a criminal background check.

  • Ordering the report too early. The FCRA lets you order a report once you have authorization. Fair chance laws make you wait until after the conditional offer.

  • Forgetting state background check laws. California's Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act adds its own disclosure requirements.

Most employers send one combined preliminary notice and one combined final notice that meet both sets of rules. Have counsel review the templates for each state and city where you hire.

For a full walkthrough of the federal requirements, including who inside your company should be allowed to see a background report, read our white paper, FCRA Compliance, Criminal-History Protections, and the Structural Failures That Create Liability.

What should employers do now?

Compare your hiring process to the steps regulators checked in these two cases.

  1. Remove criminal history questions from every application. Check online forms and third-party applicant tracking systems as well as paper applications.

  2. Review job ads. Take out phrases such as "clean record required" or "no felonies."

  3. Move the background check to after the conditional offer wherever the law requires it.

  4. Use a written individualized assessment form. Record the offense, how long ago it was, and how it relates to the duties of the job.

  5. Fix your notices. Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act templates don't include what California, Philadelphia or New York City require.

  6. Track the response deadline. Five business days in California and New York City, and ten in Philadelphia.

  7. Train everyone who touches the process. Recruiters and hiring managers need to know what they can't ask, and reviewers need to know how to assess a record.

  8. Check your contractors and vendors. Confirm that staffing agencies, contractors and background check companies follow the same steps.

  9. Keep the paperwork. Save each assessment, notice and applicant response.

An HR compliance audit is a good way to test all nine at once.

Frequently asked questions about the Ralphs and FedEx Fair Chance Act settlements

Question Answer
What is California's Fair Chance Act? The Fair Chance Act is California's ban-the-box law. It took effect in 2018 and generally bars employers with five or more employees from asking about conviction history before a conditional job offer. It also requires an individualized assessment and written notices before an employer withdraws an offer because of a conviction.
How much did Ralphs pay to settle the Fair Chance Act lawsuit? Ralphs agreed to pay $200,000 to four applicants. It also agreed to remove conviction questions from its California job applications, revise its notices, hire a consultant, train staff and report to the state for three years. The settlement was announced July 9, 2026 and requires court approval. Ralphs did not admit wrongdoing.
Why did FedEx pay $85,000 under the Fair Chance Act? A contractor rejected an applicant for a FedEx driving job because of an old and unrelated offense. California's Civil Rights Department found that required steps were skipped, including an adequate individualized assessment and notice of the final decision. FedEx settled without admitting liability and agreed to train staff and revise its notices.
Can a California employer ask about criminal history on a job application? No, unless an exception applies. Employers with five or more employees cannot ask about or consider conviction history until after a conditional offer of employment. The Ralphs lawsuit alleged that the company's application asked the question before any offer was made.
What is an individualized assessment? It is a job-specific review of an applicant's conviction history. In California, the employer must consider the nature and gravity of the offense, how much time has passed, and the nature of the job. An offer can be withdrawn only if the conviction has a direct and adverse relationship to the specific duties of the position.
How long does an applicant have to respond before a job offer is withdrawn? In California, at least five business days after receiving the preliminary notice, plus at least five more if the applicant disputes the accuracy of the record. Philadelphia gives applicants ten business days. New York City requires at least five business days.
Is an employer responsible when a contractor or staffing agency rejects an applicant? It can be. In the FedEx case, a contractor made the rejection, and the complaint named both FedEx and the contractor. FedEx paid $85,000 and agreed to change its own procedures. Companies should confirm that contractors and staffing agencies follow the same fair chance steps.
Did the EEOC eliminate the rules on criminal background checks? No. On October 28, 2026, the EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records. Title VII still prohibits discrimination, and state and local fair chance laws in California, Philadelphia, New York City, New Jersey and elsewhere remain fully in effect.
Does Pennsylvania have a ban-the-box law for private employers? Not statewide. Pennsylvania law limits how employers use criminal records and requires written notice when a record is the reason for a denial. Philadelphia has its own ordinance, which bars criminal history questions until after a conditional offer and applies to employers with one or more employees.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Fair chance and background check laws vary by state and city and change often. Consult employment counsel about your specific situation.

About CHRO, LLC

CHRO, LLC is an attorney-led fractional HR firm based in the Philadelphia suburbs, serving employers in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, New York and nationwide. As your Outsourced CHRO, we review job applications, background check procedures, individualized assessment forms and adverse action notices against the fair chance laws and Fair Credit Reporting Act requirements that apply where you hire. We also provide HR compliance support for regulated providers that must run criminal history checks, and manager training for recruiters and hiring managers on what they can ask and when. Our FCRA compliance white paper covers the federal rules in detail.

Sources

The Ralphs and FedEx cases

California's Fair Chance Act

Federal law and the EEOC

Fair Credit Reporting Act

Pennsylvania and Philadelphia

Other states and cities

Next
Next

Lockheed Martin's $29.5 Million DEI Settlement: What Employers Must Check Now